magnaflow check engine light problem - CustomTacos.com Forum
Go Back   CustomTacos.com Forum > The Garage > Exterior/Body > Lights / Exterior Electricals

CustomTacos.com is the premier Toyota Tacoma Forum on the internet. Registered Users do not see the above ads.
Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 04-13-2005, 09:46 AM   #1
hezy
Newbie
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 18
Default magnaflow check engine light problem

I installed the cat-back system brand new from magnaflow on my 04 V6 4x4 DC taco a week ago and the CEL came on after I drove it for about 20 miles. I have 9000 miles on the truck right now. I have done a reset 3 times now and after about 20 miles of driving the light comes on and stays on . Magnaflow techs tell me the reset takes care of this problem. I have not been to the dealer yet. Autozone read a 420 code. This is really pissing me off. Anyone else have this same problem and resolve it? Does the Borla sytem do the same? IShould I keep this thing or return it to magnalfow? Any feedback would help.
hezy is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
Old 04-13-2005, 11:01 AM   #2
TacoWithCheese
Grand Tacoholic
 
TacoWithCheese's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: 2-son, Terror-zona
Tacoma: 2002 Tacoma Prerunner double cab V6 3.4L
Posts: 7,453
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

i think Tred had this problum. he went through like two 02 sensors. you should PM him.

but do a quick comb over and see if you forgot a gasket or forgot to plug in the o2 sensor. or check if the gasket isnt leaking.
TacoWithCheese is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 04-13-2005, 02:35 PM   #3
Tred
Grand Tacoholic
 
Tred's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: North end of Arizona
Tacoma: 2002 3RZ-TFE 1BAR
Posts: 11,616
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

Hmmm, Magnaflow won't help you. That's new.

I suggest you to not take it to the dealer, regardless of what Magnaflow says. Magnaflow will tell you to have it checked out by the dealer, but most likely your truck is perfectly fine. Some aftermarket catback systems occasionally cause CELs, often for P0420. Magnaflow's is notorious for causing CEL. I've never heard of any other manufacturer's aftermarket catback systems causing CELs.

You have a few options:
1) Say to hell with Magnaflow, and join me in spreading the word that they suck. Then return the Magnaflow catback system, and go to your muffler shop and have them make a catback system for you with brand new piping, or simply have them replace the OEM exhaust with an aftermarket one (assuming you didn't chop up the OEM catback). Or you can make your own catback system in your garage for very cheap, but I assume you don't have the proper tools and skills to do so. Otherwise you would have done that already.

2) Live with the CEL being on. (...Which unfortunately many people do.)

3) Get the O2 Simulator from Gadget from www.urdusa.com. This will hopefully get rid of the CEL.

4) Try to spend a lot of money and try to get the Magnaflow to work.

I, being a dumbass that I am, went with Option 4, and wasted $800 total with the purchase of the catback system, diagnostic tools, new O2 sensors and visitations to the dealership. So $800 later, I'm bone stock.

If you don't particularly love the exhaust tone from the system, and if you have the luxury to return it, don't bother trying to get it to work. Send the damn thing back. Their service sucks anyways. My guess is that, if my truck was Turboed or Supercharged with fuel mods, it could handle the catback without triggering the CEL.

I don't know about Borla's system, but I highly recommend you to look into your local exhaust shops. Catback systems don't give that much performance increase anyways, especially if your engine is bone stock without Forced Induction. So, if that's the case, a simple muffler swap will give you the same Sound change.

Like I said, I've wasted $800. I could have been 1/3 my way to a supercharger if I hadn't been a dumbass. I hope this helps.

Oh, and try posting nasty comments on their customer comments section on their website. A gentleman by the name of Craig Lieberman will contact you.
Tred is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 04-13-2005, 02:45 PM   #4
Tred
Grand Tacoholic
 
Tred's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: North end of Arizona
Tacoma: 2002 3RZ-TFE 1BAR
Posts: 11,616
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

This will get a little long, but for all (who's having issues with their catback system) to know, I'm posting the email comms between myself and Mr. Lieberman here.

Quote:
Dear Sir/Madame;

I read your post on our site. Iím sorry youíre having difficulties with one of our systems. Please feel free to call our Engineer, Richard Waitas at 949 858 5900 to discuss your issue in greater detail.

We feel this is more appropriate way to handle your difficulty than an anonymous post on our site as ultimately, our primary concern is your satisfaction with our product, or our ability to help you identify the true problem.

Please give us the opportunity to serve you to your satisfaction.

Sincerely,

Craig Lieberman
Marketing Director
MagnaFlow Performance Exhaust
22961 Arroyo Vista
Rancho Santa Margarita, CA 92688
Quote:
Mr. Lieberman,

Thank you for contacting me regarding the issue I was having with one of your catback systems.

However, unfortunately, it is a fact that your catback system #15811 causes check engine lights on my 2002 Toyota Tacoma for P0136 and P0420. I have found another owner of this same catback system whose truck gets a CEL of P0420. I understand you are the Marketting Director, so I will keep the technical jargon out of this as much as I can.

I have been working on making your catback system work since December of 2004, and I have spent over $400 for purchasing the system, and another $400 for diagnostic, and other tools. I had several opportunities to talk to Mr. Waitas over the phone. He has been very helpful, and has given me numerous useful suggestions. Furthermore, I have purchased an OBD II scanner, replaced the rear O2 sensor twice, and replaced the front O2 sensor once. I have also taken the truck to the dealer multiple times for diagnostics and repair.

Your limited lifetime warranty lists that you warrant the product to be free from defects. As far as I am concerned, as a general consumer, a catback system that causes CELs is defective. Mr. Waitas indeed agreed that the catback system should not cause CELs and blamed my vehicle. Furthermore, he had stated that there is nothing that Magnaflow can do to help me with running my truck CEL free. Another suggestion made by Mr. Waitas was to purchase a fuel mod that will allow me to monitor and adjust the air fuel ratio and mixture. Unfortunately, most of these equipment cost upward of $200. Especially after spending $800, I am not willing to spend another $200 blindly.

Even though your limited lifetime warranty statement includes the following:
"The manufacturer does not assume any responsibility for any consequential damages occasioned by the muffler, or inconvenience or interruption in any operation."
I feel that a disclaimer should be added that your catback systems do cause check engine lights on Toyota Tacomas.

While the other owner ignores his CEL, I cannot do such thing. I believe that if the catback system needs additional tools to be made compatible with my vehicle, it is not truely a bolt-on, even though you state in your FAQ page that "They come with everything needed to bolt up in place of your factory system using basic tools."

Five months and $800 later, unfortunately, I found that the only solution to a CEL free truck was to remove the Magnaflow Catback. I am now using the OEM exhaust, and Magnaflow catback system has been sold to another Tacoma owner I met on an online forum for $100 as is. I lost $300 as I originally purchased the system for $400.

I am grateful that you have contacted me, and offered to assist in troubleshooting the issue. However, the opportunity had already been given to Magnaflow several times, and I have been told that there is nothing that can be done. At this point, the best I can do is to steer away all Toyota Tacoma owners and all other general consumers from purchasing your products.

Again, I appreciate you taking the time writing me a message. If you feel there are other opportunities for you to serve me to my satisfaction, please feel free to contact me.

Sincerly,
Quote:
Thank you for your thoughtful reply...it is always a pleasure to do business with a customer who is polite and seeking a real solution to a real problem.

Obviously, weíre very concerned that youíre having a repeated problem.

I've spoken with the head of R&D who had this response:

I do recall an issue for a 15811 back about 4 months ago (I think it was this issue) however I cannot recall ever telling someone to purchase or take any such actions on their own. In most cases, my recommendation is to take the vehicle to a dealer if under warranty ... if it is a 2002, it should still be covered. I would have explained potential causes based upon codes but not asked an end consumer to take it upon themselves to remedy the issue nor purchase diagnostic equipment. I did say however if he was curious to know about how his vehicle was running you can monitor such things with stoichemeters and he wanted to know a little bit more about how the performance of the vehicle would be affected.

On the technical side, a PO130-170 code refers to an oxygen sensor fault and a PO420-30 refers to a catalyst fault. Both are related to O2 FUCNTIONALITY. Problems within the O2 circuit or in just the O2 sensor in it self can cause the problem. From testing, even dramatic reductions in backpressure cannot lend themselves to cause such problems.

We had tested 4 chassis under that portion of development and had run sound testing and dyno testing and have NEVER been able to duplicate this issue.

My last though would be to check the part in the fixture. If perchance someone in production did not weld the bung correctly (angle and protrusion) a change in sample exhaust "might" cause a PO420 code but still the PO136 cannot be attributed to that.


All this aside, in clearer English, there is a possibility that there is an 02 sensor problem OR, that the 02 sensor bung WE installed on the system is slightly out of alignment.

Since we have not heard of any other problems with this system, either of these two items seem likely causes ASSUMING there are absolutely ZERO other modifications to the vehicle.

If it were me, Iíd return the vehicle to stock, take it back under emissions warranty and have it checked. From your response, it appears that you havenít been back to the dealer. I can appreciate your desire to address the problem at home, but even with my fairly technical background, Iíd opt to have it analyzed by Toyota-trained techs rather than spend money on expensive diagnostic equipment (but if youíre like me, you probably like having the tools anyway.)

You should also know that in rare cases where CELís ARE an issue, our systems are put on HOLD until a cure is found and in some cases, we never release a system. These are few and far between and with no other complaints on record for CELís on Tacomas (we have 6 guys who do nothing but answer tech calls all day long), it still seems that thereís a 50% chance that there is an existing issue with the vehicle. Again, a dealer diagnosis might help us find a resolution.

Going back through our detailed ďcomplaintsĒ report, we were only able to find one other complaint on a Toyota. It was a 2.7L motor. The CEL was on after an installation. Disconnecting the battery and reconnecting after 30 minutes cleared the problem.

You sound pretty savvy, so Iíll assume youíve done that. If youíve been to a dealer and can fax me a diagnosis report, Iíll take this matter to the highest level in the company and see what I can do for you in the way of a refund or other compensation. Our ultimate goal is to make you happy, so thank you very much for giving us the opportunity to do so.

Craig Lieberman
Quote:
Hello Craig.

Thank you for the immediate response.

First, I need to remind you that I do not have the catback system any more. But for your reference, I will provide you the information I have.

Rich did not recommend me to buy any additional tools, except for the fuel mod. That was his very last suggestion when I called at the begining of the month, when he also told me that there's nothing that can be done. Please do understand that there is nothing against your technicians. Your folks have been great, but the catback had caused some mental and financial pain for me.

Here's the chronological order of what happened.

Upon receiving the catback system towards the end of November, it was immediately installed the same evening. My truck had about 37,000 miles on it then. It took about 300 miles for the CEL to come on. I checked all bolts and clamps to make sure I did not have a leak, and visually inspected the O2 sensor and made sure it was seated correctly. I went to Autozone, had them read the DTC (of P0136 - O2 Sensor Circuit Malfunction (Bank 1 Sensor 2)), and had it cleared. After this, the DTC kept coming back after two drive cycles (as the Factory Service Manual says it will if there is an issue).

I purchased my OBDII scanner from http://www.ghg.net/dharrison/ and also personally replaced the ear O2 sensor with an OEM one over Christmas. During this time with the OBDII Scanner, I was seeing intermittent voltage drops to zero on the rear O2 sensor.

The truck has seen the dealership 5 times since January. The Magnaflow catback system was removed for when I brought the truck in to the dealership. There are no other modifications. Day one, they pulled the code of P0136, and cleared it. Then of course the CEL came back with the same DTC, so a week later the mechanics at Toyota found that the front (A/F) O2 sensor is dead, and ordered the part to be installed. (My OBDII scanner showed no signs of the front sensor being dead. It was reading properly. I think it was a misdiagnosis on Toyota's part.)

After the front sensor had been replaced, the CEL returned in two drive cycles with the same DTC of P0136. The truck was brought in for the forth time, when I also brought in printouts of my OBDII scanner showing the intermittent voltage drops to zero. Until this forth day at the dealership, the mechanics had not been able to see the intermittent voltage drop that I have been seeing ever. They ordered the sensor, and scheduled me in again.

Day five at the dealership, the rear O2 sensor was installed. I waited about 50-100 miles while occasionally monitoring the voltage (which was normal with no voltage drops) before I reinstalled the Magnaflow. I was thinking that it indeed was my truck causing all these issues, until at 300 miles after the replacement of the rear O2 sensor, the CEL came back on with, this time, a DTC of P0420 - Catalytic Converter Efficiency Below Threashold. The Magnaflow was immediately removed, and stock was put back on. A few drive cycles later, the CEL disappeared, and P0420 became inactive.

The truck has had the OEM exhaust on since mid march, and I have not gotten any DTCs. I do not have any other modifications done to the truck.

I've visually inspected the O2 sensor mount, and the weld looks fine, and location, angle, and depth seem the same as the OEM O2 sensor mount. Of course I don't have any fancy tools to measure the depth to the fraction of a milimeter or the angle for that matter, but it looked pretty close, if not the same, to OEM specs.

Yes, I have tried disconnecting the battery.

I have three diagnosis reports from the dealership, but I am not sure if these would be of any benefit to you. For the most part, all it says is "Scanned for codes. P0136." and "Replaced sensor."

Again, I need to remind you that I do not have the catback system any more. It has been sold to another Tacoma owner for $100. Therefore, I do not believe you would be able to issue me a refund or any other type of compensation.

I appreciate your time and commitment.
The last reply from me was sent on April 8th, 2005. I have not heard from him since.
Tred is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 04-14-2005, 06:34 AM   #5
Tfunk
Addict
 
Tfunk's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Crown Point, Indiana
Tacoma: 97 Tacoma Xtra cab 2wd 2.4 5 speed
Posts: 776
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

mine used to throw CEL's when i first got my magnalfow catback system, and the CEL eventually turned off itself
Tfunk is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 04-14-2005, 08:30 AM   #6
zero4
Tacoholic
 
zero4's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Northridge, CA
Tacoma: 01' DCab 3.4L
Posts: 2,946
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

Quote:
1) Say to hell with Magnaflow, and join me in spreading the word that they suck. Then return the Magnaflow catback system....
zero4 is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 04-14-2005, 10:01 AM   #7
2 tacomas
Tacoholic
 
2 tacomas's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Northern Virginia
Tacoma: 2006 Xtra Cab Tacoma (TRD Sport,4x4, 4.0L, Auto)
Posts: 1,592
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

Quote:
Quote:
1) Say to hell with Magnaflow, and join me in spreading the word that they suck. Then return the Magnaflow catback system....

I second that
2 tacomas is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 04-14-2005, 06:15 PM   #8
hezy
Newbie
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 18
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

Did you guys take off the 02 gasket and put it on the magnaflow pipe when you did the system install. I was told to do this today by the toyota dealer. I left the gasket on the old pipe and thought it was part of the old pipe. I reset the computer and no light yet. I will keep you guys posted.
hezy is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 04-14-2005, 06:59 PM   #9
Tred
Grand Tacoholic
 
Tred's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: North end of Arizona
Tacoma: 2002 3RZ-TFE 1BAR
Posts: 11,616
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

The O2 gasket, of course, was put on the Magnaflow when I installed my catback. I'm sure others did too.

"Gas leakage on exhaust system" is one of the causes of P0420, so your mechanic might be right.

Keep us posted.
Tred is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Old 04-15-2005, 04:30 AM   #10
hezy
Newbie
 
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 18
Default Re: magnaflow check engine light problem

I drove it to work today(20 miles) and no CEL yet. Maybe I fixed it. I would hate to go through getting return approvals and finding a box to ship it back in. I threw out the original box it came in. I will keep you guys posted on what happens. Thank for your feedback TRED
hezy is offline   Reply With Quote Quick reply to this message
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
Reply

Quick Reply
Message:
Options

Register Now

In order to be able to post messages on the CustomTacos.com Forum forums, you must first register.
Please enter your desired user name, your email address and other required details in the form below.
User Name:
If you do not want to register, fill this field only and the name will be used as user name for your post.
Password
Please enter a password for your user account. Note that passwords are case-sensitive.
Password:
Confirm Password:
Email Address
Please enter a valid email address for yourself.
Email Address:

Log-in

Human Verification

In order to verify that you are a human and not a spam bot, please enter the answer into the following box below based on the instructions contained in the graphic.



Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may post new threads
You may post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:45 AM.



© Copyright 2001-2008 CustomTacos.com. CustomTacos.com is privately owned and is in no way affiliated with Toyota Motor Corporation.
Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© AutoGuide